Embeddedadvisor
US
APAC
EUROPE
  • Home
  • Insights
  • Whitepaper
  • Conferences
  • Newsletter
  • Subscribe
  • News
  • About us
Go to...
  • Home
  • Insights
  • Whitepaper
  • Conferences
  • Newsletter
  • Subscribe
  • News
  • About us
  • Categories

  • IP Design
  • Embedded Design and Solutions
  • Automotive
  • Electronics Design and Solutions
  • Aerospace
  • More
      • Imaging & Machine Vision
      • Medical Devices
      • PCB Design/Engineering
      • Test/Measurement
      • Wireless Technology
      • Telecom
      • Wearables/Sensor
      • Consumer Electronics
      • Memory/Storage
      • IoT
      • Industrial Computing
Go to...
  • Categories

  • IP Design
  • Embedded Design/Solutions
  • Automotive
  • Electronics Design/Solutions
  • Aerospace
  • Imaging & Machine Vision
  • Medical Devices
  • PCB Design/Engineering
  • Test/Measurement
  • Wireless Technology
  • Telecom
  • Wearables/Sensor
  • Consumer Electronics
  • Memory/Storage
  • IoT
  • Industrial Computing
×
#

Embedded Advisor Weekly Brief

Be first to read the latest tech news, Industry Leader's Insights, and CIO interviews of medium and large enterprises exclusively from Embedded Advisor

Subscribe

loading

THANK YOU FOR SUBSCRIBING

  • Home
  • Insights
  • IP Design
Editor's Pick(1 - 4 of 8)
left
Safeguarding Most Important Wealth - Intellectual Property

Richard Caron, CIO & VP of Business Process Management, Isola Group

Some Simple Steps You can Take to Keep Devices Secure

Aaron Gette, CIO, The Bay Club Company

Only IPv6 has the backbone to carry the IoT

Richard Jimmerson, CIO, ARIN

Leveraging Operational Excellence through IoT in Aerospace

David Jarvis, VP/CIO, Honeywell Aerospace

Artificial Intelligence in Our Innovations

Joseph S. Codispoti, Chief Intellectual Property Counsel, BEDGEAR

5 Misconceptions Executives and Engineers Have about Patents

Steven G. Saunders, Co-Chair Intellectual Property Department/ Patent Attorney, Nutter

Blockchain: When Reality Meets Utopia

Nathaniel Karp, Chief Economist, BBVA Compass

How Autonomous Vehicles Perceive and Navigate their Surroundings

Anand Gopalan, CTO, Velodyne LiDAR, Inc.

right

IP acquisition. What We Actually Buy

By Santiago Fernandez-Gomez, VP of IC Design, Genia Technologies

Tweet

Santiago Fernandez-Gomez, VP of IC Design, Genia Technologies

A few years ago, I led the development of a relatively small IP in the SERDES application space. The design effort was measured in weeks, with about three months applied to verification. We then engaged our first customer who wanted to replace the transmitter side of an existing solution provided by a market leader. We were confident on our verification efforts, and helped the customer deploy our IP using an FPGA to demonstrate an end-to-end working prototype. Then trouble started. Two months later, countless hours of debugging and lengthy three-way engineering meetings, we finally discovered that the third-party receiver was not 100 percent compliant with the standard. A 5 minutes change to the IP resolved the issue, marking the end of major engineering effort of discovery, and a management nightmare.

"When dealing with IP, you are mainly buying a head-start on verification"

Sometime earlier I had been involved as a customer in the acquisition of a silicon-proven IP with an outstanding track record and close to a billion parts in the market. The expectation was set for minimal verification. Months later, and countless hours of debugging by the silicon design team, the OS team, and Application Software teams, we were able to determine that the IP had a bug that prevented us from releasing our product. What apparently passed as an unnoticed failure for the existing hundreds of millions of parts using the IP in other products, turned out to be a showstopper issue for us, and once again a major engineering effort of discovery.

Plenty of similar examples exist in the past 25 years, where I have been both, at the receiving and delivering ends of the Semiconductor IP business, dealing with well over one hundred IPs. My experience can be summarized as “When dealing with IP, you are mainly buying a head-start on verification. The cost of the IP does not necessarily correlate with how far ahead you are actually getting.”

IP complexity and the need for differentiation in the marketplace have been main drivers undermining success with IP. On one hand, feature-rich demand and complex standards have expanded the verification challenge to the point that full coverage is only possible for the simplest of IPs.

Differentiation has brought an increase in customization and, in some cases, deviations from standards, creating problems for both, IP customers and providers, which in most cases need to significantly augment their verification efforts. It is at this point where the cost/benefit trade-off between acquiring versus developing IP comes into question.

As I look back at my long past experience in this space, I realize that my number one criteria for selecting IP has been the expertise of the provider, and the single most important learning: “buy support”.

tag

Semiconductor

Read Also

Artificial Intelligence in Our Innovations

Artificial Intelligence in Our Innovations

Joseph S. Codispoti, Chief Intellectual Property Counsel, BEDGEAR
5 Misconceptions Executives and Engineers Have about Patents

5 Misconceptions Executives and Engineers Have about Patents

Steven G. Saunders, Co-Chair Intellectual Property Department/ Patent Attorney, Nutter
Blockchain: When Reality Meets Utopia

Blockchain: When Reality Meets Utopia

Nathaniel Karp, Chief Economist, BBVA Compass
How Autonomous Vehicles Perceive and Navigate their Surroundings

How Autonomous Vehicles Perceive and Navigate their Surroundings

Anand Gopalan, CTO, Velodyne LiDAR, Inc.

Weekly Brief

loading
Top 10 IP Design Service Companies - 2020
Top 10 IP Design and Solution Companies - 2020

IP Design Special

Featured Vendors

  • The Western Design Center: Guiding The Past, Present And Future Of Microprocessor Technology
    The Western Design Center: Guiding The Past, Present And Future Of Microprocessor Technology
  • LN2: Novel Phy Decoding Engines for Improved IOT Connectivity
    LN2: Novel Phy Decoding Engines for Improved IOT Connectivity
  • Fractal Technologies: One-Stop-Shop for IP Design Validation
    Fractal Technologies: One-Stop-Shop for IP Design Validation
  • Brass Roots Technologies: Specialist IP Core-Powered Solutions
    Brass Roots Technologies: Specialist IP Core-Powered Solutions

I agree We use cookies on this website to enhance your user experience. By clicking any link on this page you are giving your consent for us to set cookies. More info

Copyright © 2021 Embedded Advisor. All rights reserved. Registration on or use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
follow on linkedin follow on twitter
This content is copyright protected

However, if you would like to share the information in this article, you may use the link below:

ip-design.embeddedadvisor.com/cxoinsights/ip-acquisition-what-we-actually-buy-nid-118.html